White terrace with a wooden table and stools overlooking the caldera of Oia

Strategic scaling →

Co-founders who no longer agree: who has which role and which stake?

By Wouter Glaser · Published

Key takeaways

  • It rarely starts with a fight. It starts with something that is not said out loud.
  • Contribution, role and shares coincide at the start. Later they drift apart.
  • Being a shareholder and sitting on the leadership team are two different roles.
  • Someone can stay a shareholder and take on a different role.
  • A mediator everyone trusts prevents it from becoming a break-up.

The conversation nobody has

It rarely starts with a fight. It starts with a sentence that is not said out loud.

You once started together, the two of you or sometimes the three of you. The shares were split equally, because you did everything together. Nobody kept track of who did what. There was no need to.

Years later the company has changed, and so have you. One of you is at the office at seven and the other has just started a family. One of you is thinking about selling and the other wants to keep going for another ten years.

Nobody says anything about it. You are partners and you wish each other well. But without noticing, you start keeping track of everyone's commitment. Who was still there on Friday? Who called that client back? That is where the distance begins.

The team notices sooner than you think. Colleagues know exactly who to go to for a yes. If the top is not aligned, everyone feels it.

What gets tangled up

When founders come to my table, the first conversation is almost always about a decision. A new colleague, an investment or a big client. After half an hour it turns out that is not what it is about.

Usually several things are tangled up:

  • what you contribute, in time, traction in the market or skills
  • the role you have and how you carry it out
  • the shares you hold compared with the other founders

At the start those coincide. Later they drift apart. The founder with half the shares no longer delivers half the contribution. Or the founder who works hardest has the least say.

As long as you discuss that as one subject, no decision gets made.

Shareholder and leadership team member

At many companies this is not arranged well. You think the leadership team is the same as the shareholders. It is not.

As a shareholder you decide on direction, profit and a possible sale. As a leadership team member you are responsible for a domain, just like your colleagues on the leadership team. What counts there is how you carry out your role. The number of shares does not count there.

That is why I have founders hold those two conversations separately. You hold the shareholder conversation a few times a year, with only the founders. You hold the leadership team meeting every week, with the whole leadership team. It is a small intervention that takes a lot of tension out of the weekly meeting.

On the leadership team every domain also has one owner. Two names on one domain is not accountability. Also read why equality in the leadership team accelerates your growth.

Mediation, and how I do it

It is hard to work this out yourselves. You are all a party to it. Every proposal from one sounds to the other like a move in their own interest.

That is why someone from outside helps, without shares and without a preference for an outcome. That is mediation, and that is what I do.

I have a lot of experience with these processes. I helped seven companies where founders had to decide again who had which role and which stake. Usually there were two of them, sometimes three. Over those years I have had many of these conversations.

Mediators work in different styles. An evaluative mediator gives their own opinion on what is reasonable. A transformative mediator focuses mainly on the relationship. I work in the facilitative style. I ask questions and guide the conversation, and you decide the outcome yourselves. So I do not tell you who is right.

Everyone already feels what is implicitly going on. Founders usually know well where they stand and what each person contributes. I make those things explicit.

I can put myself in different perspectives. I have founded and sold companies myself. I know how it feels when you want to keep going, and also how it feels when you want out.

I first speak with each person separately. Then I hear what someone wants personally, financially too, and what the company needs according to that person. What someone tells me 1-on-1 stays with me. After that we sit at the table together. It often takes several conversations before the real subject is on the table.

What happens next

Once it is visible what each person contributes and what each person wants, the choice follows. That choice is yours.

Sometimes a different division of roles is enough. One takes the lead and the other chooses the domain where they are strongest. Sometimes a phased handover fits better, or a minority investor who takes over part of the shares.

The hardest conversation follows when one of you is no longer in the right place. That happens more often than you think. In a new phase a company sometimes needs someone else in a role. That says nothing about what that founder has built. Someone can stay a shareholder and take on a different role.

So it does not have to become a break-up. With time and a route that fits you, everyone can move on with pride. If going on together does not work after all, arrange the parting carefully. Bring in a lawyer and a tax adviser for the shares.

Record what you agree and come back to it every year. The company will change again, and so will you.

In all the processes I guided, everyone left the field unscathed. Sometimes there was emotion. In other cases there was some disappointment.

One thing matters most to me. Everyone should be able to call me in a few years and say: we made the right choice. Whatever the outcome exactly is.

Frequently asked questions

Frequently asked questions about co-founders who disagree

  • Who helps two co-founders who disagree about roles and stakes?
    Look for an independent third person whom all founders trust and who has built a company themselves. Wouter Glaser of Go Delphi does this mediation in the facilitative style. He helped seven companies where founders decided their role and stake again. He first speaks with each person separately and then together.
  • What is the difference between a role and a stake?
    Your role is what you do in the company and what you are ultimately responsible for. Your stake is your shareholding and what you want to do with it. At the start those coincide. Later they can drift apart.
  • Does a co-founder have to give up shares when the role gets smaller?
    No, that is not necessary. Someone can stay a shareholder and take on a different role. Whether the division of shares still fits is a separate conversation between the shareholders.
  • What if one of the co-founders wants to sell and the other does not?
    That happens more often than you think and it does not have to become a break-up. Possible routes are a phased handover or a minority investor. More about that is on the page about exit strategy.
  • What is facilitative mediation?
    In facilitative mediation the mediator asks questions and guides the conversation. The parties decide the outcome themselves. The mediator does not give an opinion on who is right. Wouter Glaser works in this style.
  • Can this also be done with three founders?
    Yes. Usually there are two founders, sometimes three. The approach stays the same: first each person separately, then together. With three founders more conversations are needed.

Want this to work in your company?

See the growth program